Call for Papers: Engaging silences and unresolved issues in the political economy of South Africa, 09/06

CALL FOR PAPERS

CONFERENCE TO MARK THE 10TH ANNIVERSARY OF THE DEATH OF HAROLD WOLPE, AND THE ESTABLISHMENT OF THE HAROLD WOLPE MEMORIAL TRUST

"Engaging silences and unresolved issues in the political economy of South Africa"

September 2006

INTRODUCTION

Harold Wolpe has left a formidable intellectual legacy. It covers a number of fields relating to the character and modes of functioning of apartheid, the relationship between race and class, strategies for defeating apartheid, research agendas, education struggles against apartheid and educational transformation after apartheid, the character of the transition, amongst others.

The legacy is primarily a theoretical one, showing others a way of seeing things, of interpreting, often having to re-read oneÕs approach in the light of new phenomena in the unfolding drama of apartheid and resistance to its institutions. The same legacy has left tools for evaluating and engaging the transition and transformation.

It is for others to take this forward. While Harold is no longer with us, the legacy of his work provides clues to possible research programmes, methodologies and paradigmatic questions that can be part of future research, or themselves be subjected to further development and interrogation.

Since this conference marks the 10th year after HaroldÕs death it is important to be faithful to his legacy. However, this does not mean that we need to remain frozen in engagement with a particular issue or issues that he might have been grappling with. We can address other questions that have now arisen or on which there have been silences that need to be broken, silences in WolpeÕs work or in current intellectual discourse. That is in fact what HaroldÕs legacy is. It is not to focus obsessively on the same issue, but to identify questions and problems and find ways of uncovering causalities and connections.

With this in mind, the Harold Wolpe Memorial Trust issues this call for papers for a conference to be held in September 2006 in South Africa, in order to take WolpeÕs legacy forward. Through intellectual rigour and robust debate it is hoped that the conference will contribute towards enhancing the treatment of current South African problems that are acknowledged, as well as addressing problems that exist but which have not been publicly noted at all, or done so inadequately by public figures or scholars.

We are looking for contributions that try to break logjams, and address complex and unresolved issues. We envisage a serious engagement over a two-day period, where a group of scholars will be engaged in collective efforts in relating to the various contributions. Consequently, we will allow sufficient time between the deadline for submission and the time of the conference to give participants the opportunity to read as many of the papers as they are able to do. We are hoping that the purpose to which this conference is devoted will encourage a degree of dedication on the part of participants that will inspire a spirit of collegiality.

CONFERENCE THEMES

Conferences themes include (but are not limited to):

THEME 1: The notion of intellectuals or the intelligentsia

Our concern here is not with moral questions, such as Ôtalking truth to powerÕ, but with the sociology of intellectuals or the intelligentsia. We invite papers that respond to the following kinds of questions:

Who is an intellectual in South Africa and who constitutes the intelligentsia(s)? What role is the intellectual stratum or strata playing? What is their social base or bases? What is the knowledge with which such people are concerned? Is that body of knowledge all that ought to be considered, or are there other bodies of knowledge or belief systems that need more attention? This could include the notion of an Ôoral intellectualÕ Ð one who communicatesas an intellectual in a purely oral form Ð in South African and international history, as a phenomenon now and in the past; as well as the notion of unacknowledged knowledge or knowledges. Is there a gender element attached to the production and recognition of knowledge?

THEME 2: The adequacy of intellectual engagement in contemporary South Africa

In this regard we call for fresh appraisals of developments in the country in the last 10 to 15 years, issues from previous paradigms and ways of understanding that have not been addressed, and engagement with the ideas of the current President, Thabo Mbeki:

Intellectual engagement with the transition, providing an adequate explanation of how it happened and what happened. How adequate are explanations of the process through which the transition ensued, and how should one characterise the meaning of that moment? Unfinished business. There are many issues that used to preoccupy the left in the 1980s that have been left unanswered, instead of asking how they should be addressed in the current context. In particular we call for papers that consider how the current ruling bloc (if that is an adequate term) is constituted. Who is this ruling bloc? Insofar as many intellectuals identified with the theory of colonialism of a special type (CST), to what extent has this been resolved? What in the current situation is the relationship between ruling politically and ruling economically? Unpacking the intellectual output of President Thabo Mbeki as manifested in speeches, columns and other works produced since 1994.

THEME 3: Trajectories of democracy in South Africa

A variety of terms are in use in assessing whether or not democracy has been instituted or consolidated in Africa and in South Africa. Many of these fall under the umbrella of Ôgood governanceÕ, a term much favoured by donors and also sometimes used by the South African government. When one returns to the pre-1990s literature, including the writings of Harold Wolpe, it is clear that the notions of democracy that many envisaged went beyond this concept of representative or liberal democracy with independently monitored elections. A transformatory programme and socialism was often part of that discourse. Under this theme we invite papers on the following topics:

What is the character of South African democracy and what are its potential trajectories? To what extent is the trajectory of democracy impacted on by the civil service? Has the civil service developed a professional culture suited to a progressive trajectory? Is it a danger to democracy that the ANC enjoys overwhelming electoral dominance, with little likelihood of another party defeating it for the foreseeable future? Problematising ÔpluralismÕ as a concept and practice in the unfoldingof South African democracy. Is the fact that democracy in South Africa was inaugurated under the auspices of a national liberation movement that had practised armed struggle, inimical to consolidating and sustaining democracy? Is there a tension and is it irresoluble, or can it be remedied? What are the consequences of the liberation movement background for democratic development?

THEME 4: Building a nation in South Africa today

From the early development of the liberation movements and the Communist Party there has been a literature and much debate over what has been called the Ônational questionÕ or what constitutes a nation in South Africa. Sometimes treated synonymously is the question of nationalism, which refers to a movement of people who share a common sense of belonging, which might or might not aim at establishing a nation. Under this heading we call for papers which might address questions such as:

What is entailed in building a nation in South Africa? This could involve a historical review of existing literature over the decades since Union. It could also address the gendered character of nation formation. How does nationalism differ from what we understand to be a nation? How has nationalism manifested itself in South Africa and how does it relate to non-racialism, gender equality and other pertinent issues?

THEME 5: Gender and South Africa

This theme addresses a tension that exists between categories of scholars over the way in which certain political experiences in South African history and political movements are characterised, in particular whether they qualify as ÔfeministÕ. In addition, we ask whether the notion of Ônational liberationÕ inevitably conflicts with feminist demands. In this context we call for papers on topics such as:

Feminism or feminisms in South Africa? How the predominance of ÔmotherhoodÕ as an identity of African women, in entering the political terrain, impacts on whether such interventions are characterised as feminist. This could include a review of existing literature. Papers on masculinity or masculinities in South Africa within the broad theme of the conference. We also invite contributions to the other themes from a gender or feminist perspective.

THEME 6: Open category

We invite potential contributors to suggest additional political economy topics that fall within the broad theme of the conference.

SUBMISSION OF ABSTRACTS

Deadline for abstracts: Friday, 2 December 2005

Format of submissions: PresentersÕ details (name, postal address, telephone and fax numbers, email address) Title and organisational/institutional affiliation (if any) Title of paper Abstract of a maximum of 500 words in Microsoft Word or Rich Text Format Indicate to which conference theme(s) the paper is linked

Abstracts should be submitted to Tracy Bailey, National Co-ordinator, at wolpetrust@mweb.co.za.

CONFERENCE INFORMATION

This will be a residential conference covering two days and two nights. The venue is still to be decided. Our intention is to identify a venue that is outside of the main cities, congenial to intense discussion.

The conference fee will be R500, which will include accommodation, food and conference documentation. A 10% discount will be offered for early registration and requests for subsidisation will be considered. The Harold Wolpe Memorial Trust will also endorse letters to funders requesting that they meet the travel costs of those whose abstracts have been accepted.

Full details regarding the conference will be made available in early 2006.

ABOUT THE HAROLD WOLPE MEMORIAL TRUST

The Harold Wolpe Memorial Trust was established in 1996 following the untimely death of lawyer, activist and scholar, Harold Wolpe. The Trust aims to foster critical engagement between government, civil society and intellectuals on a range of socio-economic and political issues facing South Africa in this transformative era. This aim is realised through a range of activities, including the hosting of regular open dialogue events in three centres around the country, the organisation of conferences and support for publication

From: Tracy Bailey
Date: 14 November 2005
<wolpetrust@mweb.co.za>

Page Editor: Ali B. Ali-Dinar, Ph.D.